Return to Syllabus
Return to Westra's Home Page
CHILD DEVELOPMENT
Matthew Westra
 (Spring 2011)
INTELLIGENCE

READINGS:  

Kinlaw, C. Ryan, and Beth Kurtz-Costes. "Children's theories of intelligence: beliefs, goals, and motivation in the elementary years.(Report). ." The Journal of General Psychology.  134.3 (July 2007): 295(17). (Link Here)   

Kohn, A. "Beware of the Standards, Not Just the Tests," September 26, 2001


Definitions:

MEASURING  INTELLIGENCEStandard Curve

We don't currently have a good grasp on exactly what intelligence IS.
How shall we measure a thing, or a characteristic whose definition we don't even really agree upon?

Basic idea of Intelligence Testing:
    If we test on elements of the culture that all people have been equally exposed to, then the more intelligent will have learned more of those elements.
    This is good in theory, but has obvious flaws in the notion that there is anything all people of a society are equally exposed to!

TYPES of TESTS:

IQ - measure by comparing mental age by chronological age

IQ = (MA/CA)100 

 Skills - measure ability to perform on task-relevant skills.



Two of my favorite quotes about Intelligence Testing:

This intelligence testing business reminds me of the way they used to weigh hogs in Texas. They would get a long plank, put it over a cross-bar, and somehow tie the hog on one end of the plank. They'd search all around till they found a stone that would balance the weight of the hog and they'd put that on the other end of the plank. Then they'd guess the weight of the stone. (John Dewey (1859-1952) American teacher, philosopher, reformer)

Intelligence tests are like weeds; they won't go away and you can't improve them with cultivation. (anonymous)

IQ STABILITY  &  PREDICTIVENESS
"So what about grades? How valid are they as predictors? Researchers have in fact had great difficulty demonstrating that grades in school are related to any other behaviors of importance— other than doing well on aptitude tests. Yet the general public—including many psychologists and most college officials—simply has been unable to believe or accept this fact."    (Testing for competence rather than for intelligence   DC McClelland - American psychologist, 1973 - lichaoping.com pg. 2)


Some challenges to traditional IQ come from advocates of the Emotional Quotient and from studies of multiple intelligences, such as Howard Gardner.


    Interesting Internet Sites   
     "Bad Science"
    Longview's Critical Thinking Across the Curriculum Site  
   Testing for competence rather than for intelligence DC McClelland - American psychologist, 1973  - This is a classic comment about issues and problems with testing. Sadly, all of the issues in this (over 35 year old) article are still relevant.

Last Modified November 29, 2010